to my wretched
i have come to see you,
i have come to see you;
but you can't even say, 'i miss you' -
o have i been so wretched a beast
as to deserve so contemptful
an anthology? best leave me be, -
please, leave me be;
for even when you leave me,
though i tried too hard to keep thee,
you keep staring at me from afar;
you keep me enclosed
in this holeless, holeless jar.
too many hither, then no one thither:
i am left to wither - o to wither
before your gaze; if only, if only:
i would give anything to just -
be with even just your haze.
'to my wretched' - this is how i have chosen to title this post. why? perhaps i was feeling especially melancholic; who can say? certainly not me. and i know how strange it must seem, for me to say that; how, after all, can you not know the feelings that in large part inform that which you are?
i am not known for being especially good with my emotions; i have trouble discerning them, i have trouble communicating them - i even have trouble conceiving of them. i do feel them, but in so blurry and hazy a fashion that the only way for me to possibly express them is through poetry. either that or my diary, but my writing becomes so exceedingly melodramatic there that, for all intents and purposes, it expresses merely an intellectualisation of my feelings; - not that that is a bad thing mind you, it certainly helps me make sense of them in some form; but it is not authentic.
why this focus on authenticity? what is, even, authenticity? i shouldn't define it singularly, far from it, for authenticity is that which makes art art; it is that spark so to speak - that's how someone who wants to be conventionally 'deep' would describe it -; or rather it is the multitude of facets of personhood which we (wittingly or not) place within our art. the precise nature of this authenticity, then, is wholly unique to the author or creator, to the artist; therein lies the issue of definition, for it is not a thing to be defined in an objective, axiomatic context - it is not a first principle; and insofar as it is unaxiomatic, it is also circular, for it defines itself through itself, and thereby, not intellectually rigorous; but i do not find this to be an issue: after all, in my Preface to icaris i did answer the question Who is Wren with the tautology 'Wren is Wren'; insofar as i am not writing an academic essay, a dissertation, or some other such work, i do not think circularity an issue. no, the important matter here is whether from an artistic standpoint the circularity and lack of scientific (and intellectual) rigour is justified. as i conceive it, it is.
when one writes a poem, the personhood they put in it isn't born from first principles; in fact, it isn't born from anything at all, in particular, but rather a haze of thoughts, feelings, sensations, all blurring together into a specific form and shape, which is set to paper (or not: i oft improvise poems i forget moments later), and which is authentic insofar as the pieces of oneself one puts in it are authentically Me ¹.
in being authentic, - defined by its authenticity, - art escapes the bourgeois conception of art that bourdieu points out in La Distinction ², for instead of being defined by arbitrary criteria that merely serve to pursue the social reproduction of the bourgeois system of exploitation (both culturally and financially i should add), it becomes something that anyone can do, truly; not in a capitalist, 'each person is the arbiter of their own success' kind of fashion, but rather in a truly popular conception of art. art need not be overwrought: but it also can be overwrought - all kinds of formal (and informal) mechanisms can be played with, so long as that which lies beneath is authentic; insofar as we are humans, it always is; and thus, any piece of writing, of drawing, any graffiti, but also a letter, or anything else one might think of, can be considered - or rather: is - art.³
¹ Me used in a collective sense, here; not 'me' in particular, the person writing this, but the Me of each individual artist.
² i ought to mention that though i do own the book, i haven't got around to reading it properly, thoroughly, which is why i am not pushing the argument and paraphrase as far as i perhaps could.
³ there is admittedly a proper difficulty with this conception: how do you define art legally? artists need rights, protection, funds, to live off their work; in fact, what is an 'artist', if anyone can make art. someone who lives off their art, i suppose, but how does one define that? i am uncertain, to be plain, and instead of spitting out some thoughtless blither i should rather leave this an open ambiguity, which i might come back to when i have thought and researched it more.